A Market Analysis by Mike Chen, Florida Real Estate & STR Specialist
As a real estate professional who works closely with short-term rental owners and investors across Central Florida, one question I’m asked often is:
The answer isn’t just one factor. It’s a combination of location, zoning, amenities, rental performance, buyer demand, and long-term investment appeal. Even as the broader Kissimmee and Osceola County housing markets have cooled in 2025, Storey Lake continues to outperform in both sales velocity and buyer interest.In this article, I’ll break down exactly why Storey Lake homes sell faster, how it compares to nearby communities like Bellalago, Reunion Resort, and Paradise Palms, and what sellers should understand if they’re considering listing a home in this highly competitive market.
Storey Lake Overview: One of Kissimmee’s Most In-Demand Communities
Storey Lake is a master-planned, resort-style community located just minutes from Walt Disney World. It spans more than 600 acres and features over 2,500 homes ranging from townhomes to luxury vacation villas.
What makes Storey Lake unique is its ability to attract three strong buyer groups simultaneously:
- Short-term rental investors
- Second-home and vacation buyers
- Full-time residents seeking resort-style living
This rare combination is a major reason why homes here consistently sell faster than in surrounding neighborhoods.
Location: One of the Closest Communities to Disney
Location remains the #1 driver of buyer demand, and Storey Lake has one of the best in Central Florida.
Key location advantages:
- Less than 10 minutes to Walt Disney World
- Direct access to Osceola Parkway and US-192
- 15–20 minutes to Universal and SeaWorld
- 20 minutes to Orlando International Airport
- Minutes from shopping, dining, and outlets
For vacation rental buyers, proximity to Disney directly impacts occupancy rates, nightly pricing, and repeat bookings. For homeowners, it means convenience and long-term value.
Resort-Style Amenities That Drive Buyer Demand
Storey Lake is designed like a luxury resort, and that matters.
Community Amenities Include:
- Resort-style pools with a lazy river
- Multiple clubhouses
- Fitness centers
- Mini golf & sports courts
- Kayak lake access
- On-site dining & tiki bars
- Golf cart transportation
- Playgrounds & game rooms
These features are a major reason why:
- Guests book Storey Lake more often
- Investors see stronger ROI
- Homes sell faster than in nearby communities
Buyers are not just purchasing a home. They’re buying into a lifestyle and income opportunity.
STR-Friendly Zoning = Faster Sales
One of the biggest reasons Storey Lake homes sell faster than other Kissimmee communities is short-term rental zoning.
STR Advantages in Storey Lake:
- Daily & weekly rentals allowed in approved sections
- Proven Airbnb & VRBO performance
- No city-wide bans like other Florida markets
- Strong HOA enforcement but STR-friendly rules
Areas such as The Cove and Hideaway Club are especially attractive to investors because they allow legal short-term rentals with minimal restrictions.
This creates constant demand from buyers, even in slower market conditions.
Strong Rental Performance Drives Buyer Interest
Storey Lake consistently outperforms surrounding markets in rental metrics.
Average STR Performance:
- Occupancy: ~77%
- ADR: ~$169/night
- Annual Revenue: $45,000–$60,000+
- Cap Rates: 6–8% depending on purchase price
- Average Booked Nights: ~280 per year
Homes with:
- Private pools
- Game rooms
- Themed bedrooms
- Strong Airbnb reviews
Sell faster and for higher prices than comparable properties elsewhere.
Market Data: Why Storey Lake Homes Move Faster
Even in a cooling market, Storey Lake remains highly competitive.
Storey Lake Market Snapshot:
- Median Price: ~$470,000
- Avg Days on Market: 51–149 days
- Sale-to-List Ratio: ~97%
- Inventory: Lower than surrounding areas
By comparison, much of Kissimmee is seeing:
- Longer days on market (60–95+ days)
- Increased inventory
- Higher price reductions
Storey Lake consistently outperforms because buyers actively search for STR-approved communities, not just homes.
Buyer Demographics Driving Demand
Storey Lake attracts a powerful mix of buyers:
Primary Buyer Groups:
- International investors (Brazil, Canada, Europe)
- U.S. vacation-home buyers
- Airbnb & VRBO investors
- 1031 exchange buyers
- Multi-generational families
These buyers are motivated by:
- Rental income
- Proximity to Disney
- Turnkey properties
- Strong appreciation history
This constant buyer pool is a major reason homes don’t sit long.
How Storey Lake Compares to Nearby Communities
| Community | Key Advantages | Key Drawbacks |
| Storey Lake vs Bellalago | ✅ STR-friendly zoning✅ Closer to Disney✅ Higher rental income potential | ❌ Bellalago is primarily residential |
| Storey Lake vs Reunion Resort | ✅ Lower HOA fees✅ More affordable entry price✅ Similar proximity to Disney | ❌ Reunion has higher operating costs |
| Storey Lake vs Paradise Palms | ✅ Newer construction✅ Larger homes✅ Better resort amenities | ❌ Paradise Palms is older with lower ADRs |
Why Storey Lake Homes Sell Faster
Homes in Storey Lake sell faster because of:
✔ Prime Disney-area location
✔ STR-friendly zoning
✔ Strong rental income potential
✔ Resort-style amenities
✔ High buyer demand
✔ Modern construction
✔ Proven Airbnb performance
✔ Global investor appeal
Few communities in Central Florida check all these boxes.
Mike Chen’s Take on the Storey Lake Market
As a Realtor specializing in short-term rental properties and vacation home investments, I can confidently say:
Storey Lake Resort is one of the strongest-performing communities in the Kissimmee market, even in a shifting economy.
If you own a home in Storey Lake and are considering selling, timing and strategy matter more than ever. Proper pricing, professional marketing, and positioning your home as an income-producing asset can make a six-figure difference in your final sale price.
Thinking of Selling Your Storey Lake Home?
If you’d like to know:
- What your Storey Lake home is worth today
- How much rental income buyers will expect
- Whether now is the right time to sell
How to market your home to investors
EN
ZH