Sunset Walk vs. ChampionsGate vs. Reunion: Which Offers the Best ROI?

For real estate investors eyeing the booming Orlando vacation market, the choices can feel overwhelming. The Orlando-Kissimmee corridor is packed with resort-style communities, each promising a slice of the magic and a healthy return on investment (ROI). Three names consistently rise to the top: Sunset Walk, ChampionsGate, and Reunion.

But while they all offer proximity to Disney and a resort lifestyle, they are far from interchangeable. Each community presents a unique value proposition for different types of investors and second-home buyers. Are you looking for a hands-off, entertainment-driven condo? A large-scale home built for multi-family groups? Or an exclusive, high-end estate for luxury clientele?

As a licensed Florida REALTOR® and a vacation rental investor myself, I’ve seen firsthand how these communities perform. 

This guide offers a data-driven comparison of Sunset Walk, ChampionsGate, and Reunion to help you determine which one aligns best with your financial goals and lifestyle dreams. We’ll break down everything from property types and pricing to rental yields and target demographics.

At a Glance: Key Differentiators

Location and Accessibility

While all three communities boast prime locations near Orlando’s world-famous attractions, their immediate surroundings offer different experiences.

• Sunset Walk: Located in West Kissimmee, Sunset Walk is just an 8-minute drive from Walt Disney World. Its biggest advantage is the Promenade at Sunset Walk, a vibrant, walkable hub of restaurants, shops, and live entertainment. With direct access to US-192 and FL-417, Orlando International Airport (MCO) is only about 30 minutes away.
• ChampionsGate: Situated southwest of Disney in Davenport, this community offers direct access to I-4, making it a strategic base for reaching Disney (15 minutes), Universal, and even Tampa. The on-site ChampionsGate Village provides essential conveniences, making logistics simple for large groups.
• Reunion Resort: Just east of I-4, Reunion offers a more secluded, private enclave feel while still being only a 12-minute drive to Disney. Its sprawling layout, featuring three signature golf courses, creates a tranquil atmosphere that feels a world away from the theme park buzz.

Investment Profile: Property Types and Pricing

The real estate offerings in these communities are tailored to their distinct brand identities.

Sunset Walk: The Modern Condo-Hotel

Sunset Walk is dominated by turnkey, fully furnished condo-hotel units. These studio, one-, and two-bedroom residences are perfect for investors seeking a hands-off experience, often managed through Hilton or Embassy Suites.

• Pricing: Studios and one-bedrooms range from $360,000 to $400,000. Two-bedrooms start around $490,000.
• HOA Fees: Approximately $655/month, covering most utilities, cable, internet, and full resort access.

ChampionsGate: The STR Powerhouse

ChampionsGate is famous for its large single-family pool homes (4-9+ bedrooms) and townhomes designed for multi-generational families and sports teams. These properties often feature game rooms and themed bedrooms to maximize rental appeal.

• Pricing: Townhomes typically run from $400,000 to $600,000, while single-family homes range from $600,000 to over $1.2 million.
• HOA/Club Fees: Around $657/month for full access to the popular Oasis Club.

Reunion Resort: The Luxury Leader

Reunion Resort offers the widest spectrum of properties, from condos and villas to sprawling custom luxury estates with 12+ bedrooms. These high-end homes often feature private theaters, resort-style pools, and golf course views.

• Pricing: Condos start near $400,000, with luxury homes ranging from $500,000 to over $4 million.
• HOA/Club Fees: Varies widely from $420 to $850+/month, with additional club membership fees required to unlock full amenity access for renters.

ROI Breakdown: Rental Yields and Performance

Your return on investment will depend heavily on which community’s model you choose.

• Sunset Walk: Delivers strong gross rental yields of 6-9% on its condo units, driven by high Average Daily Rates (ADR) of $175-$350/night. Occupancy is consistently high (65-75%) due to bookings from Hilton/Marriott channels and a packed events calendar.
• ChampionsGate: A safe bet for reliable cash flow, with an estimated annual occupancy of 61% and ADRs from $300-$700+ for larger homes. Well-managed 5-9 bedroom homes can gross $47,000 to $88,000+ annually.
• Reunion Resort: Offers the highest potential upside but also more variability. Top-performing luxury homes can achieve 60-70% occupancy with incredible ADRs of $700 to $1,200+ per night. However, higher HOA and management costs can eat into net yields if not managed expertly.

Amenities and Lifestyle

The lifestyle in each community is a major draw for both owners and renters, directly impacting booking rates and guest satisfaction.

• Sunset Walk: This is an entertainment paradise. The main draw is the walkable Promenade, featuring over 20 restaurants and bars, live music, a movie theater, and the Island H2O Water Park. It’s an “urban resort” where something is always happening.
• ChampionsGate: The Oasis Club is the heart of the community, boasting a massive clubhouse, a lazy river, water slides, a tiki bar, and a sports complex. Complemented by championship golf courses, it’s designed for active, multi-generational families.
• Reunion Resort: Unmatched in luxury and scale, Reunion features three signature championship golf courses (designed by Nicklaus, Watson, and Palmer), 11 pools, a full-service spa, and six upscale restaurants. The focus is on discreet, high-touch service and exclusivity.

Which Community Is Right for You?

Choosing between these three premier communities comes down to aligning your investment strategy with the right market.

Choose Sunset Walk if:

You want a hands-off, turnkey investment with strong branding and a built-in entertainment district that drives bookings. It’s ideal for investors seeking high ADRs and a vibrant, urban resort lifestyle.

Choose ChampionsGate if:

Your goal is to generate reliable cash flow from large family and group rentals. Its proven STR model, extensive family-friendly amenities, and scalable management make it a favorite for portfolio investors.

Choose Reunion Resort if:

You are targeting the high-end luxury market. Success here requires a premium, often custom-themed property and expert management to attract discerning clients, corporate retreats, and VIP guests willing to pay for exclusivity.

Unlock Your Orlando Investment Potential

Navigating the Central Florida vacation rental market requires local expertise and a deep understanding of what drives ROI. As both a real estate professional and a vacation home operator, I provide my clients with data-driven insights to make confident decisions.

Whether you’re drawn to the lively energy of Sunset Walk, the family-centric model of ChampionsGate, or the exclusive luxury of Reunion, I can help you find the perfect property to meet your goals.

Contact me, Mike Chen, your Orlando vacation home specialist, for a personalized consultation and to explore current listings.

Have questions?
Click to schedule a time to talk

503-888-8070